Fresh, local delicious fish served up by the nicest duo. Had amazing clams that I steamed, and we grilled fresh tuna on the bbq. That and the chunky flavorful fish dip made for an outstanding dinner. Thanks Peterson's! They plan to be open year round, which will be great for Montauk.

Peterson’s Seafood is, simply, terrific. Incredibly fresh fish, direct from Wes’s buddies’ boats. It literally can’t get any fresher, unless you catch it yourself. As good as the seafood is, the guys do an even better job at the counter. From advice about how to prepare the fish to tips on shucking oysters - they’ve got you covered. A real “locals” store in town, with a super convenient location near the beach.

The world’s freshest fish!!!! I have been a local for over 20 years and was overwhelmed with this place. With Covid ruining most businesses finally we have a true, local Mom and Pop fish market with better and fresher stuff than big chains. Loved it!

Bought some extremely fresh fluke, a little panko and the griddle and it was amazing! Our new favorite fish market in Montauk! Doug was a fantastic salesman too.

Guys who served us were great. Very personable and very helpful. The lobsters were super fresh.

These guys are friendly, knowledgeable, service is great, they are fisherman so they know their fish and it’s a good vibe. Support local.